Skip to main content

March 25th, 2010 at 7pm

Speaker

Ilil Naveh-Benjamin (Cornell University, Science and Technology Studies)

Title

Red Marbles and Electric Shock Machines: Foucault and the Ethnography of Psychology

Abstract

Numerous historical and philosophical accounts of experimental psychology have invoked Foucault to understand psychology’s role in the governance of individuals (e.g., Nikolas Rose, Ian Hacking, Stephen Ward, Ellen Herman, Jill Morawski, and others). Focusing on psychology’s language of variables and methods of quantification, such accounts have asked how psypower legitimizes and normalizes a particular vision of the calculable individual in modern liberal democracies.

In this talk, I suggest that a Foucault-nourished critical space, while offering important insights regarding psychology’s macro social impact, presents unique challenges to the microscopic interests of ethnography. Namely, assuming ethnographers might care about how psychologists make

knowledge – that is, why they choose the methods they do and how they interpret their data – then what often gets left out of the Foucauldian story is the reality of psychology as a knowledge-making endeavour, whatever its power effects might be. Some Foucauldian accounts, on this view, cohere poorly with the imperfect, improvised, diverse, and reflexive character of psychologists’ everyday efforts at calculation. Based on 6 months of ethnographic research in an American social psychology lab, I describe the considerable challenges my informants (faculty, graduate students, and research assistants) faced in trying to capture, predict, and characterize mental phenomena quantitatively. More importantly, I argue that these researchers were not only aware of these challenges, but also actively sought to refashion experimental control in a flexible way, not in order to quantify and calculate willy-nilly, but in order to find a good balance between rigor and verisimilitude – or experimental control and construct validity.

Directions

York University (Keele Campus)

  • Address: Room 214, Calumet College
  • TTC: Take the subway to Downsview station. Take the 196 York University bus to the York University Commons stop. Walk north, through the Student Centre, outside to the Campus Walk. Proceed west to Calumet College (see campus map below).
  • Driving Directions
  • Parking: There are a number of pay parking lots on campus. All of which are shown on the campus map below. Rates at each lot vary.
  • Map
  • Campus Maps
  • Leave a Reply